I switch from State Farm to GEICO about 4 years ago. I have carried State Farm for well over 20 years, and even whne I was in the military stationed in the states.
When I switched to GEICO it saved me just over $200 on a 6 months policy just when State Farm was policy was going up. So that saved me over $400 a year and I had better coverage than I carried with State Farm.
When I bought my Mercedes and only had that one vehicle, my rates jumped up because of the expenseive car and no multiple vehicle discount, but it was still cheaper than anybody else. Later I purchased a used 2002 Toyota Highlander for my daily driver, and added it to the policy. I also dropped the annual mileage I was putting on my Mercedes from 15K down to 5K per year and now I pay $25 less for both vehicles than I did for the Mercedes alone. I should mention here that I do not carry collesion or comprehensive insurance on the Toyota
As previously stated, GEICO's customer service is excellent. You can handle almst anything online or over the phone.quickly and efficiently. Why pay a commission to an insurance agent for just writing up the application and trying to gouge you for stuff you don't need.
We have a claims agent in town and when I got an estimate and a check to cover damage to my old Sport Trac, the body shop tried to claim that there would be more damages because he knew that the bumper brakets would be all bent up. My claims adjuster went to the body shop and inspected the damage and found the other guy was just blowing smoke. He said that there was only an $8 part that was needed and GEICO would cut him a check for the additional $8.
A similar thing happened with my Mercedes when I hit some road debris that damaged the spoiler under the bumper. The actual nose piece was $250 more than the GIECO agent had in his books (brand new vehicle) but the body shop had already checked with the agent and got it straight before I even picked up my car.
So overall I have to give GEICO an A+ for Value and Customer Service. State farm was always a good company, but the agent I had was worthless.
...Rich