How far is her drive to work?
Short winter trips will affect fuel economy worse than if you put a lower-temp thermostat in your cooling system. Air-fuel ratios are affected by coolant temperatures, so until the engine is fully warmed up you'll be using considerably more gas than normal.
I bought my '03 ST in Ohio on Halloween, got 18.5 mpg on each fill-up on my way home with it. Switched to Mobil 1 Extended Performance 5W30 before a trip to Florida in December... range was 19-21 mpg on that trip. Then I changed my rear differential & transfer case fluids last month just before it got colder here... my economy hasn't improved, but it hasn't gotten worse either. I suspect when outside temps warm up again I'll see my daily mpg get better too.
The worst mpg I've gotten so far was 12, but I did probably 30-40 short start-stop cycles while moving firewood from one area to another in my yard (lot is 420' long). Going short distances, cold temps, and frequent starting kills the fuel economy of any vehicle.
Being that you don't know the history of maintenance, I'd recommend changing all of the fluids, the thermostat, spark plugs, and new air filter, possibly have someone check the performance of your oxygen sensors too.
Maybe you can persuade Mrs. Justin that since you're replacing them for "maintenance reasons" that you can upgrade to a CAI, less-restrictive exhaust (for better mpg), or whatever else if you're wanting to mod it.
TJ