I am the one not to be trusted becasue I charge for my services wheras the parts stores do it for free,
No, it is because repair shops charge extra for things like "shop supplies".
Seriously?
If you went to Wal*Mart to buy a loaf of bread and they charge you for the reciept paper and ink, would you not complain?
This is the cost of doing business.
A friend took his vehicle to the dealer for some repair. I know what "flat rate" is, but get real. He was charged 4 hours for a job that was done in 30 minutes. Of course, if it took 5 hours, they would have come up with some excuse that "something else was wrong too" to make up for that extra hour.
A guy at work took his car in to a shop because it was making a noise. They could not reproduce the noise. He paid the fee and left. Got less than a mile down the road and heard the noise. He went back to complain and they sent the tech out with him. He could hear the noise, but the tech couldn't. The tech was partially deaf. SERIOUSLY?!?!?!? This is how they operate?
My sister had a Taurus SHO that had some running issues above 3500 (or so) RPM. Four dealerships could not figure the problem out, but they all replaced parts that was going to fix it, but never did. A Porsche machanic found the vacuum leak in 10 minutes and charged her a 20 dollar bill. The previous mechanic even had the courtesy to crack a spark plug when he changed the new Motorcraft plugs that I already replaced a week earlier.
Another guy at work had an issue with his Dodge truck having a misfire under a moderate load. After 3 different dealers replaced just about every sensor under the hood, he was into this thing spending over $3,000.00. Still the same issue. He even asked the dealer if the O2 sensors could cause this problem. the response was always, "no, that is impossible". He had enough. He went home and replaced the O2 sensors himself and the issue went away. Two years later and the problem is still gone.
So, while you seem like a very honest guy and if I lived close to you, I would give you some work if it wasn't something I couldn't (or don't want to) handle. Unfortunatly, seperating the honest from the dishonest mechanics is very difficult. So, in my book, all mechanics are dishonest.
I am fully capible of doing a job wrong or removing and replacing parts that are not bad. I refuse to pay someone to do do a job wrong or to replace parts that are not bad.
Tom